Crippling with Compassion?

Strange title? It comes from teacher Ellen Berg’s article in Teacher Magazine, Teaching Secrets: Don’t Cripple With Compassion. From her perspective, “One of the major issues with American teachers especially is our predilection to rescue kids instead of letting them struggle with the content a bit. In essence, we’re too compassionate.” It is second nature for us as teachers to help our students, but do we rush in on rescue missions too often and too soon?

Berg writes, “I get how difficult it is to step back and let them struggle, but I also know that it’s in the disequilibrium that kids have to make sense of things and that’s when the learning happens. If we do it for them, why would they be persistent with a problem or give it more than 30 seconds? And how can they become confident, self-directed learners if we don’t ever let them have that experience? Finally, why would they ever believe that they are able to figure it out if we show them by our actions that we don’t believe they can, either?”

Thinking of how we math teachers might challenge students to tough thinking, I looked around for problems that would work in middle school classrooms. Here are a few below, but please share any of your favorites from the classroom in the comments section.

Balanced Assessment

A set of more than 300 assessment tasks actually designed for off-the-wall thinking. Most tasks, indexed for grades K-12, incorporate a story problem and include hands-on activities. Some intriguing titles include Confetti Crush, Walkway, and Hockey Pucks. Rubrics for each task are provided.

Understanding Distance, Speed, and Time Relationships

In these two lessons, students use an online simulation of one or two runners along a track. Students control the speed and starting point of the runner, watch the race, and examine a graph showing time versus distance. Students can use the activity to come to conclusions on the distance, speed, and time relationship. They can also use it to consider the graphical representation and the concept of slope.

Measuring the Circumference of the Earth

Through this online project, students learn about Eratosthenes and actually do a similar measurement that yields a close estimate of the earth’s circumference. It’s a challenge! Even with access to only one computer, students can obtain data from other schools that lie approximately on their own longitude. Careful instructions guide the students in carrying out the experiment and analyzing the data collected. The project also provides activities, reference materials, online help, and a teacher area.

Down the Drain: How Much Water Do You Use?

Students first collect data from their household members and their classmates and then determine the average amount of water used by one person in a day. They compare their average to the average amount of water used per person per day in other parts of the world. Through the Internet, they can collect and share information with other students from around the country and the world. A teacher’s guide is included as well as guidelines on how students can publish reports, photos, or other work directly to the project web site.

Accessing and Investigating Population Data

In these activities, students use census data available on the web to examine questions about population. They also formulate their own questions. For example, in one section they analyze statistics from five states of their choice, develop specific research questions using the data, and create three graphs to compare and contrast the information.

The Handshake Problem

This two-lesson unit allows students to discover patterns in a fictional but real-world scenario: How many handshakes occur when the nine Supreme Court justices shake hands with each other? Students explore—through a table, a graph, and finally an algebraic formula—the number of handshakes in any size group. A second pattern is explored, that of triangular numbers; again, students generalize the pattern with variables. The lessons are well illustrated and include background information for the teacher.

These problems require patience and analytical thinking, even the easiest of them. I would not give such problems without having prepared my students with the needed tools to do them, if not before they start the work, then as they’re doing it. As Ellen Berg put it, “I’m not talking about failing to scaffold instruction or give kids input. Of course we want to do that. What I’m talking about is resisting the urge to fix things for them instead of asking more questions to get them thinking. I’m talking about sometimes just telling them, ‘I know you can do this,’ and walking away.”

Another teacher who feels that we need to help math students less is Dan Meyer, a high school math teacher. This 11-minute talk, Math Needs a Makeover, begins with: “I teach high school math. I sell a product to a market that doesn’t want it but is forced by law to buy it.” From there he moves to actual examples of textbook math versus ways to present real, hard thinking problems. Worth watching!

Citation: From Teacher Magazine [Teacher Update], Wednesday, May 26, 2010. See

We Want Your Feedback
We want and need your ideas, suggestions, and observations. What would you like to know more about? What questions have your students asked? We invite you to share with us and other readers by posting your comments. Please check back often for our newest posts or download the RSS feed for this blog. Let us know what you think and tell us how we can serve you better. We appreciate your feedback on all of our Middle School Portal 2 publications. You can also email us at Post updated 4/12/2012.

12 thoughts on “Crippling with Compassion?

  1. With a minor in mathematics, and now that I currently teach math, I wish I was taught to let students struggle. It is very difficult to sit back and watch my students become frustrated, helpless, and give up when you want them to succeed. I think it would be beneficial to let the student’s know what your expectations are when problem solving before you find yourself in my situation. If you have a challenging atmosphere and the students are aware that you will not solve it for them, it makes them more independent learners.

  2. hey there and thank you for your information – I’ve certainly picked up anything new from right here. I did however expertise several technical points using this site, since I experienced to reload the web site many times previous to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your hosting is OK? Not that I am complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will often affect your placement in google and can damage your quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I’m adding
    this RSS to my e-mail and can look out for much more of your respective exciting content.
    Make sure you update this again soon.

  3. Hello! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site?
    I’m getting sick and tired of WordPress because I’ve
    had problems with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be awesome if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  4. Do you have a spam issue on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; many
    of us have created some nice practices and we are looking to swap solutions with others,
    be sure to shoot me an e-mail if interested.

  5. It іs typiсally only recommended being used short term, as the long term
    effects have not been established, quite yet.
    Would therde be less deсisions made tha were not
    about money, and makinng everyboody happy and prosperous. Taking
    the central bunkers or positions gives you good field control iin general.

    Heree iѕ my site – optimal stack and 1285 muscle review –,

  6. We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.
    Your website offered us with valuable information to work on.
    You have done an impressive job and our whole community will be
    grateful to you.

  7. Not only is it now overpopulated with your competition, but it is also overrwhelmed with status updates by thhe millions of accounts.
    Some people do choose to invite coworkers, managers, and
    other professionals because they are intentionally using Facebook too
    leverage their career brand. The problem is, most people are teaching the wrong way to do this.

  8. There’s nothing mortgage rates quite like a vaccine; this effect and regression-to-the-mean. Polygonum multiflorum
    is a virus, which have anything to do things to be considered mortgage
    rates and seen as customers. Thick tomes now abound
    on this with your mood. The bile that it can help speed up the works.
    One advertisement shows two men in the development of TCM on the inside
    of the consumers, it does to a weakened state.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *